Property Law

Taxation Aspect of Property Sale and Purchase

Background

Business sale and purchase of property has been demanded by many people. In performing the business sale and purchase of property, it does not only need an agreement between seller and buyer, but there are things that shall be performed by both parties as one of the obligations to State. The relevant obligation is payment of a tax in acquisition of property that should be performed by buyer and seller.

In Indonesia, it has been known some types of tax that has to be met by seller and buyer in business sale and purchase of property, as follows:

1. Land and Building Tax (L&B Tax)

The regulation on L&B Tax is contained in the Law Number 12 of 1985 on Land and Building Tax as amended by the Law Number 12 of 1994 on the Amendment of Law Number 12 of 1985 on Land and Building Tax (“L&B Tax Law”).

Based on the Elucidation in Article 3 paragraph (2) of L&B Tax Law, L&B Tax is a state tax which is the majority of its revenue is a regional income that is used for the provision of facility that is also enjoyed by the Central Government and Local Government. In the beginning, L&B Tax is a tax where is its administration process is performed by the central government and all revenues are distributed to the regions with a certain proportion. In the next development, the Law Number 28 of 2009 on Regional Tax and Retribution (“Law No. 28/2009”) is applied in which the entire management process of L&B Tax, especially in rural and urban sector will be performed by local government. Tariff of L&B Tax which is imposed to tax object is 0, 5%.

Based on the Minister of Finance Decree Number 362/KMK.04/1999 on the Grant of Land and Building Tax Reduction, as amended by the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 110/PMK.03/2009 on the Amendment of Minister of Finance Decree Number 362/KMK.04/1999 on the Grant of Land and Building Tax Reduction, the amounts of L&B Tax incentive are:

• Taxable Sales Value (NJKP) of 20% for the Tax Object Sales Value (NJOP) < Rp 1 Billion; • The grant of Tax Object Sales Value which is not imposed Tax (NJOPTKP); • The grant of reduction because of certain condition of tax object which is related to the tax subject and/or because of other specific causes. 2. Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building (Bea Perolehan Hak Atas Tanah dan Bangunan / BPHTB) The regulation on Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building is governed in the Law Number 21 of 1997 on Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building as amended by Law Number 20 of 2000 on the Amendment of Law Number 21 of 1997 on Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building (“BPHTB Law”). Under the Article 1 paragraph (1) of BPHTB Law, Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building is a tax which is imposed to the acquisition of right of land and or building. The Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building is imposed to the buyer (Article 2 paragraph (1) and paragraph (2) of BPHTB Law). Tariff of Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building is 5% (five percent). Under the Minister of Finance Decree Number 561/KMK.03/2004 on the Grant of Acquisition on Right of Land and or Building Reduction, as amended by the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 104/PMK.01/2005, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 91/PMK.03/2006 on the Second Amendment of Minister of Finance Regulation Number 561/KMK.03/2004 on the Grant of Acquisition on Right of Land and or Building Reduction, the incentive of Acquisition Levy on Right of Land and Building property are: The grant of Tax Object Sales Value which is not imposed a Tax (NPOPTKP); The grant of reduction because of certain condition of taxpayer which is related to tax object and/or because of other certain causes. 3. The Income Tax of the Income from Transfer on Right of Land and Building (the Income Tax in Article 4 paragraph 2) The regulation on Income Tax on The Income from Transfer on Right of Land and Building is set forth in the Article 4 paragraph (2) of Law Number 7 of 1983 on the Income Tax, as amended by Law Number 7 of 1991, as amended by Law Number 10 of 1994, as amended by Law Number 17 of 2000, as amended by Law Number 36 of 2008 on the Fourth Amendment of Law Number 7 of 1983 on the Income Tax ("Income Tax Law"). Income tax which is imposed to the income of transfer on right of land and or building is 5% (five percent) of gross amount of transfer on land’s or building’s value. Income tax of transfer on right of Simple House and Simple Condominium which is performed by taxpayer that is his/her principal business to transfer on right of land and/or building is 1% (one percent) of gross amount of transfer value. Under the Article 4 paragraph (2) of Income Tax Law, the income that may be imposed the final tax are: a. the income of deposit interest and other savings, bond interest and state debenture, and saving interest which are paid by the cooperative to the individual cooperative member; b. the income of lottery prize; c. the income of shares and other securities transaction, derivative transaction which is traded on the stock, and the share sale transaction or transfer of equity shares in the company's partner which is earned by venture capital company; d. the income of transfer of asset transaction in the form of land and/or building, construction service business, real estate business, and rent of land and/or building; and e. the other certain incomes, which is set by or under a Government Regulation. Based on the provision in the Article 4 paragraph (2) letter d, it may be concluded that the income of sale and purchase of property transaction is imposed to the income tax. Under the Government Regulation Number 48 of 1994 on Payment of Income Tax on Income from The Transfer on Right of Land and/or Building, as amended by Government Regulation Number 27 of 1996, as amended by Government Regulation Number 79 of 1999, as amended by Government Regulation Number 71 of 2008 on the Third Amendment of Government Regulation Number 48 of 1994 on Payment of Income Tax on Income from the Transfer on Right of Land and/or Building, the incentive of income tax on the income from transfer on right of property land are: The Income Tax Exemption for individual person who has an income below the tax exempt income (PTKP/Penghasilan Tidak Kena Pajak) which is performing the transfer on right of land and/or building with transfer gross amount less than Rp 60,000,000.00 (sixty million Rupiahs) and is not a broken amount; The imposition of 1% (one percent) tariff from the gross amount of transfer value on the transfer on right of Simple House and Simple Condominium which is performed by Taxpayer which is the essential business is performing the transfer on right of land and/or building (general tariff of 5%). 4. Value Added Tax (VAT) The regulation of VAT is set forth in the Law Number 8 of 1983 as amended by Law Number 11 of 1994, as amended by Law Number 18 of 2000, as amended by Law Number 42 of 2009 on Third Amendment of Law Number 8 of 1983 on Value Added Tax of Goods and Services Value and Luxury Sales Tax (“VAT Law”). Under the Elucidation of VAT Law, Value Added Tax is a tax on the consumption of goods and services in the Custom Area which is imposed in multilevel in every production and distribution lines. Custom Area is the region of Republic of Indonesia which covers land, water, and air space above it, and certain places in the Exclusive Economic Zone and continental shelf which is applied to the Law that is set out of customs. Tariff of VAT is 10% (ten percent) of transaction value. Article 4 paragraph (1) of VAT Law states that the VAT is imposed on: a. delivery of taxable goods in the Customs Area which is performed by the entrepreneur; b. import of taxable goods; c. delivery of taxable services in the Customs Area by entrepreneur; d. the utilization of Intangible Taxable Goods from the outside of Customs Area in the Customs Area; e. the utilization of Taxable Services from the outside of Customs Area in the Customs Area; f. export of Tangible Taxable Goods by a Taxable Entrepreneur; g. export of Intangible Taxable Goods by a Taxable Entrepreneur; and h. export of Taxable services by Taxable Entrepreneur. The Exception for the VAT Collection 1. For Simple House and Very Simple House Under the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 36/PMK.03/2007 on the Limitation of Simple House, Very Simple House, Simple Condominium, Pondok Boro, Student Dormitory, and other houses, which is based on Delivery is Exempted from Value Added Tax, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 80/PMK.03/2008, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 31/PMK.03/2011 on the Second Amendment of the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 36/PMK.03/2007 on the Limitation of Simple House, Very Simple House, Simple Condominium, Pondok Boro, Student Dormitory, and other houses, which is based on Delivery is Exempted from Value Added Tax; the Simple House and Very Simple House which is exempted from Value Added Tax is a house which is the acquisition is cash or financed through subsidized or not subsidized credit facility, or through the financing based on the Islamic principle, which meets the following provisions: a. The building area is not more than 36 m2 (thirty-six square meters); b. The sale price is not more than Rp 70,000,000.00 (seventy million Rupiah); c. It is the first house that is owned and used alone as a residence and not transferred within a 5 years period of time since it is owned. 2. For Simple Condominium Under the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 36/PMK.03/2007 on the Limitation of Simple House, Very Simple House, Simple Condominium, Pondok Boro, Student Dormitory, and other houses, which is based on Delivery is Exempted from Value Added Tax, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 80/PMK.03/2008, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 31/PMK.03/2011 on the Second Amendment of the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 36/PMK.03/2007 on the Limitation of Simple House, Very Simple House, Simple Condominium, Pondok Boro, Student Dormitory, and other houses, which is based on Delivery is Exempted from Value Added Tax; Simple Condominium which is exempted from Value Added Tax is a multistory building which is built in an environment that used as a dwelling place which is equipped with bathroom (WC) and kitchen either united with dwelling or separate unit with communal usage, which is the acquisition in cash or financed through subsidized or not subsidized credit facility, which meet the following conditions: a. the selling price of each dwelling include condominium is not more than Rp 75,000,000.00 (seventy five million rupiahs); b. building area of each dwelling is not more than 21 m2 (twenty-one square meter); c. the construction refers to the Minister of Public Work Regulation which manages the Technical Requirement of Condominium’s Construction, and d. It is the first residential unit that is owned, used alone as a residence and is not transferable within 5 (five) years since it is owned. 3. For Simple Ownership Condominium (Rumah Susun Sederhana Milik/ Rusunami) Under The Minister of Finance Regulation Number 155/KMK.03/2001 on the Implementation of Value Added Tax which is exempted on Import and/or Delivery of Certain Taxable Goods that is Strategic, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 363/KMK.03/2002, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 371/KMK.03/2003, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 11/PMK.03/2007, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 31/PMK.03/2008 on the Fourth Amendment of Minister of Finance Regulation Number 155/KMK.03/2001 on the Implementation of Value Added Tax which is exempted on Import and/or Delivery of Certain Taxable Goods that is Strategic; Simple Ownership Condominium is a multistory building which is built in an environment that used as a dwelling place which is equipped with bathroom (WC) and kitchen, either united with dwelling or separate unit with communal usage, which is the acquisition is financed through subsidized or not subsidized ownership house credit, which meet the following conditions: a. The area for each residence is more than 21 m2 and not more than 36 m2; b. The sale price for each residence is not more than Rp 144,000,000; c. It is intended for an individual person who has an income which is not more than Rp 4,500,000 per month and has had a Tax Identification Number (TIN); d. The construction refers to the Minister of Public Works Regulation on the technical requirement of simple condominium construction, and e. It is the first residence unit that is owned, used alone as a residence and is not transferred within a 5 years period of time since it is owned. 5. Sales Tax on Luxury Goods (Pajak Penjualan atas Barang Mewah/ PPnBM) Sales Tax on Luxury Goods is a tax which is imposed on the taxable luxury goods in the Customs Area (the Elucidation of Article 8 paragraph (2) of VAT Law). Under the Article 8 paragraph (1) of VAT Law, the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods tariff is set forth as the lowest of 10% (ten percent) and the highest of 200% (two hundred percent). The export of taxable luxury goods is imposed a tax with the 0% (zero percent) tariff. The Sales Tax on Luxury Goods tariff for luxury residential groups such as luxury house, apartment, condominium, town house, and a type similar to it is 20% (twenty percent). Sales Tax on Luxury Goods is imposed to only 1 (one) time when delivery of taxable luxury goods is performed by entrepreneur who produces or imports of taxable luxury goods. Under the Article 5 paragraph (1) of VAT Law, the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods is imposed to: a. delivery of taxable luxury goods which is performed by entrepreneur who produces the goods in the Customs Area in business or work activities; and b. import of taxable luxury goods. On delivery of taxable luxury goods by producer or on the import of taxable luxury goods, beside it is imposed a VAT, it is also imposed a Sales Tax on Luxury Goods on the consideration of: a. need a balance of taxation between low-income consumers and high-income consumers; b. need to control of consumption pattern of taxable luxury goods; c. need a protection of small or traditional producers; and d. need to secure a state revenue. Under the Minister of Finance Regulation Number 620/PMK.03/2004 on the Type of Taxable Luxury Goods besides motor vehicle which is imposed the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 35/PMK.03/2008, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 137/PMK.011/2008, as amended by Minister of Finance Regulation Number 103/PMK.03/2009 on the Third Amendment of Minister of Finance Regulation Number 620/PMK.03/2004 on the Type of Taxable Luxury Goods besides motor vehicle which is imposed the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods, the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods in the form of: The restriction of the Sales Tax on Luxury Goods imposition is only imposed to the luxury residence groups such as luxury house, apartment, condominium, town house, and a type similar to it from non-condominium type with a building area of 350 m2 or more and from the type of condominium with a building area of 150 m2 or more. Alsha Alexandra Kartika

read more

Government Regulation Number 44 of 1994 on Occupancy of Home by non Owner.

Background

The purpose of the issuance of Government Regulation Number 44 of 1994 on Occupancy of Home by Non-Owner (“GR No. 44/1994”) is made to ensure fairness and legal certainty of the owner, renters/lessee or occupant in the use of the house and to implement the provisions of Article 12 and Article 13 of Law Number 4 of 1992 on Housing and Residential (“Housing and Residential Law”). This Housing and Residential Law is revoked and replaced by Law Number 1 of 2011 on Housing and Residential Area (“Housing and Residential Area Law”). On this day, GR No.44/1994 is still valid and it has revoked the Government Regulation Number 17 of 1963 on the Principles of Implementation of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law on Permanent Housing (“GR No. 17/1963”) and Government Regulation Number 49 of 1963 on Relations of Housing Operating Lease (“GR No. 49/1963”) as amended by Government Regulation Number 55 of 1981 (“GR No. 55/1981”) and all their implementing regulations so long they regulate the lease of a house.

Contents of GR No. 44/1994.

House is a building that serves as a residence or dwelling and means of fostering family (Article 1 paragraph (3) No. 44/1994). House can be occupied through lease. Under Article 1 paragraph (3) GR No. 44/1994 it is stated that leasing is a condition where the house is occupied not by the owner based on the lease agreement. Further, leasing is based on a written agreement between the landlord and tenant. It is regulated that a house that is in a dispute shall not be leased (Article 4 paragraph (1) & (3) GR No. 44/1994).

If a house is rented out over the land that is owned by other party, then under Article 4 paragraph (1), the leasing can be performed after obtaining the consent of the owner of the land and the approval must be in writing (Article 5 paragraph (1) & (3) GR No. 44/1994). With regards to the amount of rent fees, Article 17 GR No.44/1994 states that it is based on the agreement between the owner and the tenant.

GR No. 44/1994 also regulates the occupancy of house that is made not through a lease. Under Article 14, Article 15 and Article 16, it is stated that the occupancy of house that is not through a lease must be based on a written agreement between the owner and the tenant.

The GR No. 44/1994 was enacted on the 26 December 1994.

read more

Criminal Act Related to Condominium

Criminal Act Related to Condominium

Criminal provisions related to condominium is regulated in Article 21 until Article 23 of the Law Number 16 of 1985 (“Law 16/1985”) on Condominium.

Article 21 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1985 regulates criminal sanction, that is stated, “Any person who is intentionally against the provisions of Article 6 of Law 16/1985, Article 17 paragraph (2) of Law 16/1985 and Article 18 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1985 shall be punished by a maximum imprisonment of 10 (ten) years or a maximum fine of Rp 100,000,000, – (one hundred million rupiah)”.

Further, in Article 21 paragraph (3) of Law 16/1985 regulates criminal sanction that is stated, “Any person by whose negligence causes infringement of the provisions as referred in Article 6 of Law 16/1985, Article 17 paragraph (2) of Law 16/1985 and Article 18 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1985, shall be punished by a maximum jail of 1 (one) year or a maximum fine Rp. 1.000.000,- (one million rupiah)”.

The provision of criminal sanction as referred in Article 21 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1985 is categorized as a crime. Whereas provision of sanction in Article 21 paragraphs (3) of Law 16/1985 is unlawful act.

In Article 22 of Law 16/1985 it is stipulated that, beside that imposed negligence criminal act as defined above, it must also comply with the provisions as referred in Article 6 of Law 16/1985, Article 17 paragraph (2) of Law 16/1985, Article 18 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1958. Under Article 23 of Law 16/1985, it is stated that, Government Regulation governing the implementation of law 16/1985 may contain punishment of jail of criminal act by maximum 1 (one) year and/or fine of Rp. 1.000.000.- (one million rupiah).

Criminal act in relation to Condominium that may be categorized as infringement and crime is any actions that are against provision in Article 6 of Law 16/1985, Article 17 of paragraph (2) of Law 16/1985 and Article 18 paragraph (1) of Law 16/1985 as follows:

1. Requirement of Technical and Administrative
The provision in Article 6 of Law 16/1985 stipulates that, the construction of Condominium shall meet the technical and administrative requirements. Furthermore, the provision of technical and administrative requirement are governed by Government Regulation. Technical requirement is defined as regulation concerning building structure, security, safety, health, convenience, and others related with the architecture, including the completeness of infrastructure and environmental facilities. While the administrative requirements are the business license of the company’s housing construction, permits of location and/or allocation, as well as building construction permit (IMB).

2. Implementation of Execution Mortgage and Fiduciary After Announcement and Notification
This provision is regulated in Article 17 paragraph (2) of Law 16/1985 which stipulates that, for the execution of mortgages and fiduciary in order to repay a debt, may only be performed after 1 (one) month after it is notified in writing to the parties concerned and published in two newspapers circulating in that area, and/or local print media, without any parties that claim the objections. Announcement and notification provisions of the obligation before the execution of mortgages and fiduciary are intended in this Law to protect the other parties’ interests.

3.Feasible Occupancy Permit
The provisions in Article 18 paragraph (1) Law 16/1985 regulates that, condominium units that have been built can be sold for occupancy after obtaining feasible occupancy permit from Government of the relevant region. Feasible occupancy permit is also
required for non-residential condominium. The provisions in this Article are intended to secure the safety, security and order of the tenants.

Sofie Widyana P.

read more

The Function of Proportional Comparison Value for the Owner of Condominium

Article 1 Paragraph 7 of Government Regulation of Republic Indonesia on Condominium (“GR 4/1988”) explains the definition of Proportional Comparison Value, is number which shows a comparison between condominium units toward the right upon the common part, common properties, and common lands.

Proportional Comparison Value may be calculated by using 2 (two) ways, which are:

[More…]

1. Based on the related amount or value of condominium units towards the total amount of building area.

2. The comprehensive value of condominium at the first time when the developer calculates the total construction costs to determine its selling price

The elucidation in the Article above states that

Proportional Comparison Value from condominium units as referred is calculated when the time developer calculates the total development cost. The price of each unit condominium towards the price of common part, common property, and common lands at the time of calculation of total development cost is used as the basis of Proportional Comparison Value. The Proportional Comparison Value is used as a basis for conducting the separation and the issuance of “Certificate of Condominium Units”, and also as a basis for determining rights and obligations of ownership and management of common part, common property, and common land.

Sofie Widyana P.

read more

Granting and Registration of Mortgage of Land

Background
Mortgage (hak tanggungan) of land is a security right over right(s) of land, along with or without other properties that constitute a unity with such land, for the settlement of certain debts, which gives the preferred position to certain creditors against other creditors (“Mortgage”). In this regard, there are procedures for granting, registration and transfer of Mortgage as stipulated in Law Number 4 of 1996 on Mortgage of Land along with Properties Related to the Land (“Law 4/96”).

Granting of Mortgage
Granting of Mortgage is preceded by a promise or covenant to grant the Mortgage as the security of payment of certain debt, which is set out in and as an integral part of the related loan agreement or other agreements that cause such debt.
The granting of Mortgage is conducted by making the Deed of Granting of Mortgage by the Land Conveyancing Officer (“Pejabat Pembuat Akta Tanah/PPAT”) in accordance with the related prevailing laws and regulations. In the event that the object of the Mortgage is the right(s) of land which is derived from the conversion of the previous rights that have been eligible to be registered but the registration has not been done, the granting of Mortgage shall be conducted simultaneously with the application for the registration of such right(s) of land.
According to Article 11 of Law 4/96, a Deed of Granting of Mortgage must include:
name and identity of the holder and grantor of Mortgage;
domicile of the parties. If there are any party that is domiciled outside the territory of Indonesia, to such party, shall also be included a choice of domicile in the territory of Indonesia. In the case that the choice of domicile in the territory of Indonesia is not included, the territory of the Land Convenyancing Office where the Deed of Granting of Mortgage is made, is regarded as the chosen domicile;
the clear determination of the debt(s) which is secured by the Mortgage;
the value of the security;
clear description of the object of the Mortgage.

Registration of Granting of Mortgage
The granting of Mortgage shall be registered at the Land Office. PPAT shall deliver the Deed of Granting of Mortgage and the other warkah to the Land Office within a period not later than 7 (seven) business days after the signing date of such Deed of Granting of Mortgage. Registration of Mortgage is conducted by the local Land Office by making the land book of Mortgage and record it in the land book of such right of land (as the object of the Mortgage) and also copy such record into the certificate of right of land concerned.
As the evidence of the existence of the Mortgage, the Land Office will issue certificate of Mortgage in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations (“Certificate”). This Certificate has the equal executorial power with the court decision which has permanent legal enforcement. The Certificate shall be delivered to the holder of the Mortgage.

read more

Condominium on the Land with Right to Build over the Land with Right of Management

Background

Article 7 paragraph (1) and (2) of Law Number 16 of 1985 on Condominium, the developer (the “Developer”) may build a condominium over the land with Right of Management (Hak Pengelolaan) (“HPL”). HPL is a right to control, given by the state which the implementation is delegated to its holder. Rights of land that may be granted over the HPL land are Right to Build (Hak Guna Bangunan) (“HGB”) and Right of Use (Hak Pakai) (“HP”). The Developer is obligated to complete the HGB or HP status of the land prior to the initial offer of any property over the land, in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulation. Therefore, the Developer must be aware of the procedure of the obtaining of such rights and other requirements related to HGB and HP over HPL land, which is set out in the Government Regulation Number 40 of 1996 (“GR 40/1996”) and State Minister of Agrarian/Chief of National Land Agency Regulation Number 9 of 1999 on Procedure of the Granting of Rights of Land and Revocation of Right of State Land and Right of Management (“Regulation 9/1999”).

read more

Law on Housing and Habitation

On 12 January 2011, the Government issued the Law Number 1 of 2011 on Housing and Habitation (“Housing Law”). By the issuance of this law, the existed law on housing Number 4 of 1992 has been revoked. This new Housing Law is divided into 2 (two) parts i.e. housing and habitation. The purpose of this Housing Law is to fulfill the public needs for housing.

read more